Skip to content
Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Matt Holtebeck

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

State Farm® Insurance Agent

Matt Holtebeck

2711 N Mason Street
Appleton, WI 54914-2180

Corner of Northland Ave & Mason St, 3rd stoplight east of Hwy 41

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Matt Holtebeck

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call or text us 24 hours a day!


2711 N Mason Street
Appleton, WI 54914-2180



Thank you for your interest in Holtebeck State Farm!

Our team has many things to be thankful for. Helping people understand the significance of the gift of life insurance is one of them. Don't forget to call us if you are storing vehicles for the winter or on the market for fun winter toys such as snowmobiles or ice fishing! If your current insurance is needing a refresh or look over, get in touch with us! Holtebeck State Farm has been a leader in the local insurance market for more than 35 years. We can help you with your Personal Price Plan for Auto Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Life Insurance and much more!! Call, email or text our office to learn more about your life insurance gift options today. Give us a call or text to schedule your appointment today, our team is here to help. We love being your local insurance needs resource!

When it comes to insurance and financial services, let Holtebeck State Farm be your first choice. We take pride in maintaining quality customer relationships built on mutual respect, integrity and financial strength. Our team would be happy to provide you with a complimentary review of your existing policies to make sure that you and your family are not only receiving the most effective coverage, but also the most value when it comes to protecting your future.

Our team is available for virtual and in person appointments.

Are you looking for new auto, home or renters insurance this year? You've come to the right place. Let our State Farm office provide you with your Personal Price Plan today. We look forward to helping you with the coverage that fits your budget.

A little bit about Matt...

I am a second-generation State Farm Agent, born and raised in Outagamie County. I grew up riding bikes until dark, canoeing, fishing, hunting, and playing sports. When I am not working you will find me spending time with my kids at sports and school events, visiting with my family, or enjoying the outdoors while boating, swimming, and riding our ATVs. Before finding my forever career with State Farm, I spent 10+ years in the information technology industry. I have a bachelor’s degree in business, and I am a WI Public Notary. Watching my father grow his agency for the many years before he retired showed me the value of not only insurance, but also what it takes to be an outstanding agent and business owner. Insuring and protecting customers is close to my heart and I am proud to have the opportunity to be a resource for financial services and insurance in our community.


Our State Farm team truly values the people that we serve. As members of the community, we are very serious about making sure that we are addressing your needs individually and efficiently. We want to learn about what is important to you so that we know how to offer you the most effective personalized protection and services. We are that good neighbor that you can partner with! Whether it’s auto insurance and home insurance, or renter’s and life insurance, we will put together a coverage package that fits your current needs and has the potential to grow with you through the many seasons of life that we experience.

The Holtebeck State Farm Team has the capacity to help you with all of your residential or commercial insurance needs. Let us help you navigate the insurance world by helping you build your personalized plan. Some common coverages and services are listed below.

• Auto • Home • Life • Flood • Renter’s • Boat • Health Supplements • Business • Condo • • UTV • ATV• Snowmobile • Camper • Financial Services • Personal Liability • Motorcycle •

If you are in Appleton, stop by out office to say hi! We are easy to find, located at the corner of Northland Ave and Mason St, 3rd stoplight east of highway 41. Our State Farm team considers not only Appleton, but much of the surrounding areas as part of our community. This includes Greenville, Hortonville, Black Creek, Grand Chute, Little Chute, Kimberly, Combined Locks, Neenah, Menasha, and many more!

We hope to hear from you soon!

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products

Banking, Mutual Funds

For renters insurance, finding the right balance means choosing accurate, appropriate limits for your personal property and liability coverage.
Jumping a car battery can be a handy skill should you or a friend need a restart. Check out this guide on the basics of how to jump start a car.
View More Articles
Skip Infinite Scroll Facebook Feed

Here at the Matt Holtebeck State Farm Insurance agency our mission is to provide a high level of service while assisting you in managing the risks of life in Appleton, Wisconsin and surrounding communities. My team and I will treat you in a caring, friendly, and professional manner when working with you on auto, home, and life insurance. My office will provide a warm, professional environment with an accommodating schedule.

Our team is proud to be an active part of the Fox Cities and Appleton area. We pride ourselves with many years of insurance and customer focused service. Please reach out for a free virtual meeting on your auto insurance, home insurance, renters insurance and financial goals!

Amanda Rome State Farm Agent Team Member

Amanda Rome

Insurance Account Representative

I joined the Matt Holtebeck Team in Appleton, WI in the summer of 2022. I grew up in the Fox Cities, and am currently in Appleton. My favorite pastime is spending time with my two boys. I also enjoy hiking, painting, crocheting, crafts, and traveling. I am a Licensed Insurance Representative for Auto, Home, Renters, Boat, Business, and Life insurance.
Shelly Walsdorf State Farm Agent Team Member

Shelly Walsdorf

Office Associate

I joined the Matt Holtebeck Team in Appleton, WI in the Spring of 2023. I grew up in the Omro, and am currently living in Neenah. My favorite pastimes are target shooting, clay shooting, watching movies and Wisconsin sports such as the Packers, Brewers, Badgers, and Bucks.
Michael Brown State Farm Agent Team Member

Michael Brown

Insurance Account Representative

I have been part of the Matt Holtebeck Team in Appleton, WI since 2023. I grew up in Wrightstown, WI and lived in the Fox Cities area my entire life. I enjoy video games, sports mostly soccer and football, reading and movies with friends.
Dave Wautlet State Farm Agent Team Member

Dave Wautlet

Account Representative

I joined the Matt Holtebeck Team in Appleton, WI in August of 2023. I grew up in Appleton and went to Appleton West HS. My favorite pastime is spending time with my family either home or at our cabin in Mountain WI. I am an avid cribbage player and I coached my daughters 12U softball team to a city championship in 2018. I am a Licensed Insurance Representative for Auto and Home insurance.
Available Positions
Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.